"The problem consists in excluding an arbitrariness of the official"

Deputies of State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation approved in the second reading the bill on write-off of debts to natural persons and the individual entrepreneurs (IE) on taxes and to contributions.

Question: "To reduce taxes is always it is useful? "

Andrey Mikhaylovich Makarov, the chairman of committee State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation under budget and to taxes, the candidate of jurisprudence:

"It is senseless to

to reduce one tax - and to increase another"

- a state Position just in that and consists that it is a question not of decrease in separate taxes, and of the fundamental direction of decrease in tax loading.

it is senseless to

to reduce one tax - and to increase another because in this case or the general tax loading does not change, or we simply shift taxes from one branch to another...

A after all taxes in essence have to be neutral always.

U us can be dot measures which will be carried out by the state, say, on branch or by any other principle, but all the same fundamentally decrease in tax loading has to be the main line!

Today tax system Russian Federation one of the best and the most loyal in relation to business tax systems.

If we will compare our tax loading to that which exists to United States of America or in Europe, we will see that ours is nearly one of the most minimum.

But what disturbs today

business and businessmen what disturbs economy? Certainly, it not the tax size , and that is called today as an institutionalizing or an administrative rent. In other words, it is bribes and requisitions...

Actually the problem consists in seriously to improve tax administration to exclude an arbitrariness of the official. That is to exclude these requisitions...

Victor Konstantinovich Glukhikh, the honourable president of the International congress of industrialists and businessmen, the former member of Committee Federation Council on industrial policy:

"There is a certain level when people understand that it is better to pay... "

- And after all decrease in taxes is too a certain measure, and, probably, in any way it is impossible to do without it.

After all there is a certain level when people understand that it is better to pay, than to be under close attention of tax services...

But, on the other hand, and control tax authorities too has to be more effective.

here from outside Federal Antimonopoly Service it especially has to be more effective than

A because now, unfortunately, it that at all is not.

Practically everywhere we see monopolism, we observe a rise in prices, but constantly we hear broadcast Federal Antimonopoly Service conversations about ukhodakh from taxes by means of various schemes.

I do not consider

Ya that we have an ideal system of the taxation, but, probably, schemes on its improvement are both in the government, and at those economists to whom the government should listen. .

Delyagin Mikhail, director of Institute of problems of the globalization, full member of the Russian Academy of Natural Sciences, Doctor of Economics:

"The taxation personally from the income of rich people has to be higher than

... "

- there is a simple rule that the taxation personally from the income of rich people has to be above the taxation of profits of corporations. Let's tell, the rich person has one million dollars and solves, to buy a workshop or the car.

If its taxation of the personal income is lower than the taxation of its corporate profit, at it these money not to invest incentive, and to eat and buy the car...