To Moscow region enterprising people found a new way of enrichment in arrangement to judicial authority at the expense of the earth. Moscow region is not famous for the minerals, but it does not prevent people to make on it the whole fortunes. For these purposes they should not work diligent in mines by means of payment. It is enough to have useful acquaintances to people which have relations to an assessment of cadastral cost of the land plots and to enter with it arrangement which will do much harm to interests of the country, but will enrich individuals.
Such case occurred recently to Moscow region. Lands situated near Moscow Volokolamsk district, JSC "Teryaevskoe" (cadastral numbers 50:07:0010306:60, 50:07:0010306:61, 50:07:0010306:59, 50:07:0010403:18, 50:07:0010403:137 and 50:07:0010403:18) became a contention subject between the judicial and executive authorities. Everything began with that the owner of sites decided to pay in budget much less than money for the land plots therefore started challenging in Regional court of Moscow their cadastral cost. With surprising speed the judge Naydenova Ludmila who made simply improbable decision – reduced the cost of sites situated near Moscow by 60 times. Thanks to its decision, the cost of the land plot on 468 270 sq.m which was estimated earlier 2402 rub the 59th cop for square meter, makes now 40 rubles for sq.m. Just the same decision extended and on other sites of their owner. Now the hundred part of such earth costs around 5-6 thousand rubles. The conclusion of a certain expert Karpenko M. S., the representing Nenets Autonomous Area "Evroekspert" became the main criterion for the scandalous decision.
Such jump in the price struck with br even those who never was interested in the cost of the land plots in Moscow region. The judge proved such decision "the market cost", which, apparently, at Naydenova Ludmila the. Further, as expected, the land at the new low price was at once sold to people who ordered examination and challenged cadastral cost in court. Considering that lands about which there is a speech, perfectly are suitable for construction of the elite cottage settlement (the earth of agricultural purpose with the right of country construction), it is possible to present only triumph of the builders who have deceived the state for the round sum.
It is a question of sites situated near Moscow which are located near the Iosifo-Volokolamsky Uspensky monastery known around the world where crowds of tourists and pilgrims, and also the Zavidovsky reserve and hunting grounds of Administration of the President of the Russian Federation constantly visit.
In these parts are giving known past and present politicians to whom journey for ordinary citizens is limited by peculiar posts of FSO which are interested at by passing cars a place of a final route. Obviously everything that the land plots in such place cost fabulous money, but, probably, not for the judge of Regional court of Moscow Naydenova Ludmila.
Should paying to br tribute of the Ministries of property Moscow region, to regional UFNS and administration Volokolamsk district which began to defend the price of these land plots. These structures could give concrete arguments of illegal decrease in tax load of the owner of land by considerable decrease in their cadastral cost. So, Management of an assessment, planning and financial controls Ministry property relations Moscow region carried out state expertize which gave all grounds to assume that conclusions of "independent experts" do not correspond to realities, and in their examination many factors, capable to affect the price of the land plots obviously did not undertake.
Should noting br that the concept "below cost price" for the land plots in Moscow region even sounds ridiculously in today's realities, especially if it is a question of the elite district (about such land plots there is a speech). Earth cost in Moscow region pays off depending on their size, location, transport availability, a landscape and other important details. Also the price depends on a class of the land plot which share on three groups: house-keeper, business and elite. The earth hundred part in Moscow region costs today from 70 thousand rubles to one million depending on a class. Around 30 kilometers from MKAD the hundred part of a country site can be got for 227754 rubles if "house-keeper" is a question of a class. In an elite place the hundred part of the same site will cost to 800 thousand rubles. Even in the most remote corners Moscow region a hundred part of the land plot of economy class can be bought a minimum for 65 thousand rubles and if it is a question of those sites which the judge estimated in 5-6 thousand rubles for a hundred part, their price is simply transcendental, but it did not confuse the representative of the law before adoption of such decision.
Such "market prices" by which determines the cost of the earth Naydenova Ludmila, today simply do not exist even if it is a question of sites in the remote and unattractive district therefore the decision of the judge on sites in Volokolamsk district is a spittle in all judicial system Russian Federation.
Should noting br that basic interest of the judge to this business does not allow to counteract effectively to such raiding to representatives of property and tax structures who submit the corresponding appeals that did not yet lead to success. Such behavior Naydenova Ludmila, according to experts, speaks about her personal interest, therefore about impartiality of the decision passed to it out of the question. Now this case will be in details considered by the chairman of Regional court of Moscow Vasilii Mikhaylovich Voloshin and Starodubov Sergei who is the chairman of Qualification board of judges of Regional court of Moscow. They will give a legal assessment to the decision Naydenova Ludmila on decrease in cadastral cost of elite country sites in Moscow region.
This precedent is indicative during reforming of judicial system which passes to Russian Federation. This decision of the judge reminds Naydenova Ludmila the governor took br Moscow region Andrey Vorobyov which in common with the deputy Aleksandromchuprakov trace a situation. It is reported that state agencies Moscow region will submit claim to court on owners of the "cut-price" land plots because of failure to pay taxes. Unfortunately, the chief executive has very limited opportunities of rather this case, after all judges are to Russian Federation persons untouchable, and the judicial system works irrespective of decisions of the governor. It is made for advantage that the mighty of this world could not put pressure upon judges, but, seemingly, some people in cloaks confuse a word meaning independence of impunity.
the decision Naydenova Ludmila Quite so looks which does not hesitate to make the resonant decision, at all without worrying about consequences. For long years of the judge to Russian Federation tried to protect itself, first of all, instead of to be engaged in protection of a law and order in the state. As shows experiment, impunity does not happen eternal and seldom leads to good, after all times promptly change.
Source: http://www.moscow-post.com/politics/sudja_schitaet_tak23623/